When can I serve a section 146 notice on my tenant? Patience is a virtue!

Published: 27/02/2019

Written by Curwens Solicitors

Toms v Ruberry [2019] EWCA Civ 128 discusses

We won’t bore you with the gory details save to say that this case involved a tenant who had failed to keep his pub in good repair. As a result, the landlord sent a default notice requiring the tenant to remedy breaches of the repairing covenants within 14 days, together with a section 146 notice.

Whilst there was no issue with the default notice, on appeal the judge held that “the landlord was not entitled to serve a section 146 notice until a default notice … had been given and the period of 14 days specified in that clause had passed without the breaches being remedied”.

The landlord had tried to argue that such a notice only required the underlying breach of covenant which could give rise to a right of re-entry to have occurred before service of the notice. This line of argument, however, was firmly rejected.

The judge emphasised that the correct breach here was the tenant’s failure to comply with the default notice, which was an event that had not happened when the section 146 notice had been served. In other words “Patience is a Virtue”!

For the avoidance of doubt, a section 146 notice must:

State the particular breach complained of
If it is capable of remedy, require the tenant to remedy the breach and
Can only be given if the tenant has failed to remedy the breach within a reasonable period of time.

These requirements only make sense if the relevant breach has occurred. The court urged parties to take a common-sense interpretation to serving section 146 notices.

Please feel free to speak to Priya Sejpal, our resident Property Litigation expert, about this matter. Priya can be contacted by email; This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.

Please note that our briefings are for informational purposes only, and do not constitute legal advice.

testimonials

Bradley of Curwens is the most highly efficient, sharp and highly skilled conveyancer I have ever used. My sale went through quickly and effortlessly with no stress at all. Conveyancing at its best. Hurrah and Thank you.

Katie from North London

Kaajal at Curwens was terrific - really friendly and unintimidating, patient in explaining the legal-speak of the severance agreement I was being asked to sign, while also being extremely efficient in processing it all! I would unreservedly recommend Kaajal and Curwens to anybody looking for friendly and painless help with any potentially daunting legal process.

Mike from Palmers Green

We had a very good experience on our house sale with Maryam and Christina. They were knowledgeable, courteous and understanding throughout. I would definitely recommend them and have no hesitation using Curwens again for any legal representation!!

The Thompsons from Finchley

I would highly recommend Curwens. They handled the probate on my late father’s estate in a highly professional manner and explained the whole process clearly. The staff are friendly and kind and dealt with any issues I had promptly. Thank you. Much appreciated.

John from Harlow

I would like to thank the Employment team, and especially Kaajal for assisting me during my redundancy. She remained calm, when I was upset and shocked. The whole process was dealt with within one week, meaning I could go on to find further employment.

Pritti from Surrey

Our purchase was sabotaged by XXXXXXXXXX, and our mortgage offer had expired. Luckily, our lender gave us a one week extension of the mortgage offer. Curwens took over, and magic happened. We completed the purchase on time. Best Service ever!

William from London

I would like to thank you Amanda for all your support during this process. I felt very pleased you were my solicitor, you gave me confidence and reassurance, I felt in very safe hands.

Anonymous

You have helped us on a fair few issues now. On every occasion you have made us feel like we were your only client at the time… we couldn’t have got through our HR situations without your guidance.

HR Director, Milbridge Group PLC

I just wanted to say thank you for all of your help with getting our office lease done. Bradley, Sandra and Sarah were so responsive and it was a pleasure working with you.

Clinton Gomer, Energy House Digital

‹ ›

GET IN TOUCH

Any data that you submit using this web form will be held by our firm as Data Controller and will be held securely for 12 months before being securely and confidentially destroyed.
Find out more Your data will not be disclosed to any third parties without your consent or as otherwise allowed by the relevant Data Protection legislation and will only be used for responding to your query (or purposes associated with that purpose).

You have the right to be informed about what data we hold about you along with other rights set out in the legislation. Further information about your rights under the data protection legislation can be found at www.ico.org.uk

Full details can be found here

(*)

Please let us know your name.

(*)

Please enter a valid phone number

(*)

Error, invalid email address or address already exists in a contact request.

Invalid Input

(*)

Please select an office

(*)

Please let us know your message.

CURWENS NEWS

Why the right Commercial Agreements can be a foundation for your business success 16/12/2024 Read more

Law Update: The Renters Rights Bill 17/12/2024 Read more

Why a “fair” division of matrimonial assets might not actually mean an “equal” split. 18/12/2024 Read more

View all latest news

testimonials

Katie from North London

Mike from Palmers Green

The Thompsons from Finchley

John from Harlow

Pritti from Surrey

William from London

I would like to thank you Amanda for all your support during this process. I felt very pleased you were my solicitor, you gave me confidence and reassurance, I felt in very safe hands.

Anonymous

HR Director, Milbridge Group PLC

I just wanted to say thank you for all of your help with getting our office lease done. Bradley, Sandra and Sarah were so responsive and it was a pleasure working with you.

Clinton Gomer, Energy House Digital

‹ ›

GET IN TOUCH

(*)

Please let us know your name.

(*)

Please enter a valid phone number

(*)

Error, invalid email address or address already exists in a contact request.

Invalid Input

(*)

Please select an office

(*)

Please let us know your message.

Blogs